Best Cold Weather Fishing Gloves – 2019 Ultimate Buyer’s Guide

When it comes to angling outerwear, gloves are a seriously underrated piece of gear.

There’s nothing worse than having frigid, clumsy fingers when trying to unhook a fish or tie a knot.

We’ve put together a list of some of our favorite glove picks for keeping digits toasty on a chilly day on the water.

Comparison of the Best Cold Weather Fishing Gloves

Product

Our Rating

Price

​Rapala Marine Fisherman Glove

Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large

Best Overall

​Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove

Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, X-Large

Runner-up

​Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice Gloves

Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice FC Nylon Back Double Layer Gloves with Full Dipped HPT Coating, Black, Large, 1-Pair

Best for the Money

​Berkley Fishing Gloves

Berkley BTNFGG NEOPENE FISH GRIP GLOVES Neoprene Fishing Gloves, Grey

Best Cold Weather Gloves for Fly Fishing

​Palmyth Neoprene Fishing Gloves

Palmyth Neoprene Fishing Gloves for Men and Women 2 Cut Fingers Flexible Great for Photography Fly Fishing Ice Fishing Running Touchscreen Texting Shooting Hiking Jogging Trekking Cycling Walking

Editor's Pick

Are Gloves Important While Fishing?

If you have the kahunas to head out to the lake after temperatures have dipped below zero, it’s important to take care of yourself. With subfreezing air and water temperatures, frostbite can be a serious threat to winter fishermen if they neglect to purchase the right gear

Gloves are one great way to keep your fingers toasty. Not only can they provide an extra safety measure, preventing extreme cold and frostbite, but they also give your fingers more dexterity when they need it most. Clumsy hands and fingers come along with very cold weather and having a lack of control could potentially result in the loss of a fish.

Having warm gloves can also provide a sense of security and comfort, eliminating some of the potential distractions that might make a fishing trip less than ideal. There’s nothing worse than feeling uncomfortable due to the temperature and not being able to fix it— gloves can help. 

Why Are These the Best of the Year?

A lot of consideration went into the decision to include these particular gloves in our “Best of the Year” list. We had our minds set on finding products that would be comfortable, fairly affordable, and over everything else, warm. Other common features you can find in a great set of cold-weather fishing gloves include:

Material 

The fabric make-up of a cold-weather glove can have huge effects on overall performance, comfort, and dexterity. Popular fabrics commonly used include Neoprene, Goretex, and Thinsulate. All have their own advantages and disadvantages associated with them. We personally like a glove that incorporates a well-rounded composite of waterproof, breathable material and a soft inner lining. 

Dexterity

The gloves on our list allow for the hand and finger movement needed to achieve fishing success. This means they’re not too thick as to limit dexterity. To achieve this, some insulation must be sacrificed, but a great pair of gloves will find the balance between warmth and range of motion. 

Durability

When working with sharp hooks, scales, and teeth, it’s important to have a pair of gloves that won’t tear. Our picks are created with abrasion-resistant material and many incorporate features like double stitching and reinforced seams for extra insurance. 

Quick Take - The Best Cold Weather Fishing Gloves

These are our recommendations for the best cold weather fishing gloves:

  1. Rapala Marine Fisherman Glove
  2. Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove
  3. Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice Gloves

Review of the Best Cold Weather Fishing Gloves

Our best of the best list was compiled with research on the features that make gloves convenient for an angler. Check it out! 

Rapala Fisherman's Gloves, Large

Pros

  • No limit to dexterity
  • Great value for the price
  • Keep your hands warm when dry
  • Non-slip grip provides great control with slimy fish
  • Nice amount of protection from sharp teeth and scales

Cons

  • Not waterproof
  • Not great for really cold temperatures
  • Tend to be on the smaller side with sizing

What Recent Buyers Report

Anglers who purchased the Rapala Marine Gloves, for the most part, were happy with how they performed in an angling setting. Users commented that these gloves are more suited for mid to low temperatures, rather than freezing, as they’ll get cold if they come in contact with water. Buyers appreciated that there was no limit to their dexterity.

Why it Stands Out to Us

These gloves make the cut for the top spot on our glove list for several reasons. First, we really appreciate the control the Rapala Marine Gloves provide when trying to wrangle a slimy catch. The non-slip grips provide the necessary traction. We’re also fans of the design, which allows for the full range of movement.

Who Will Use This Most

The Rapala gloves are a good option for anglers who fish in cold, but not TOO cold, fishing settings. We wouldn’t recommend these to ice fishermen, but for those heading out on a chilly autumn morning, these would be an awesome pick. They offer a good amount of warmth and don’t limit movement needed to tie knots, set hooks, etc..

Bottom Line

Although these gloves won’t work for all cold water angling settings, they do their job well in many regards. We’re fans of these gloves because they are affordable, provide great control over the fish, and can eliminate some of the fear of being cut up by scales or teeth.

Glacier Glove ICE BAY Fishing Glove, Black, X-Large

Pros

  • Comfortable fit
  • Don’t limit dexterity
  • 100 percent waterproof
  • Made with high-quality neoprene
  • Shark skin texture on outer layer provides awesome grip

Cons

  • Not very durable
  • Not very breathable
  • Could be a little warmer

What Recent Buyers Report

Those who purchased the Glacier gloves had many positive things to say about them, but one praise stuck out above all others; they’re completely waterproof. Buyers were excited about this aspect and also enjoyed the grip strength and comfortable fit. However, some wished the design could be a little more durable.

Why it Stands Out to Us

The Ice Bay Fishing Gloves make an appearance on our list because we love several of their features. Like buyers, we also think the 100 percent waterproof design was a great choice on the company’s part. We were also impressed by the design, which is thin enough to allow for dexterity and movement but can still provide warmth and comfort.

Who Will Use This Most

One thing reviewers were very excited about in relation to these gloves was their versatility. Not only can the Ice Bay Gloves be used in an angling setting, but they also do a great job keeping hands dry and toasty for farming activities, gardening, skiing, the list goes on and on.

Bottom Line

Overall, the Ice Bay Glacier Gloves are an exceptionally versatile pick that can work well for a wide range of anglers. Although they could use an improvement when it comes to durability, overall, these gloves are an awesome choice that can contribute to angling success.

Memphis Glove N9690FCL Ninja Ice FC Nylon Back Double Layer Gloves with Full Dipped HPT Coating, Black, Large, 1-Pair

Pros

  • Keep hands dry
  • Comfortable, snug fit
  • Awesome value for the price
  • Made with high-quality materials
  • Multi-layer design with abrasion protection

Cons

  • Not durable
  • Fit is inconsistent
  • Limit hand and finger movement

What Recent Buyers Report

Recent buyers of the Memphis Glove were pretty happy overall with the value of this product. Anglers were surprised at how dry and warm these gloves kept their hands throughout the day but wished they were a little less bulky to allow for better hand and finger movement.

Why it Stands Out to Us

These gloves are making an appearance on our best of the best list as our budget pick because we love their performance on the water. Not only are they super affordable but they provide a comfortable fit and keep an angler’s hands dry and warm through a long day on the water.

Who Will Use This Most

These gloves are a great option for anglers who want an exceptional glove at a super reasonable price. For those of you on a budget and can’t afford to spend a fortune on a piece of gear, look no further. These gloves are a high-quality pick at a low-quality price.

Bottom Line

Aside from some minor flaws including durability issues and some clunkiness, these gloves are an exceptional pick for anglers looking to save a bit of cash. They’re still made with high-quality construction and materials and provide warmth and comfort throughout a day of fishing.

Best Cold Weather Glove for Fly Fishing:
Berkley Fishing Gloves

Berkley BTNFGG NEOPENE FISH GRIP GLOVES Neoprene Fishing Gloves, Grey

Pros

  • Attractive design
  • Great value for the price
  • Stretchy, form well to hands
  • Good amount of gripping traction
  • Nice protection from spikes and teeth

Cons

  • Don’t provide a ton of warmth
  • Not waterproof, get waterlogged easily
  • Grip padding makes them a little awkward to grab with

What Recent Buyers Report

The majority of anglers who went for the Berkley Fishing Gloves were pretty satisfied with their performance with slimy fish. They appreciated their abrasion protection and stretch-fit but wished they provided more warmth and had a waterproof coating to keep hands dry. Anglers also praised the reasonable price. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

Berkley is a reliable company that consistently puts out high-quality products at a reasonable price. These fishing gloves are a great example of their company’s standards. We especially enjoy the stretch-to-fit design of these gloves, which allows for a snug, customizable fit with plenty of dexterity for the intricate movements required for some angling activities. 

Who Will Use This Most

We have this pair of gloves listed as our pick for fly fishing, and indeed, these are an awesome choice for fly anglers who need a little extra grip. Although these aren’t the best choice for super-cold weather, for mild to low temperatures, these can provide the extra control needed to dominate a catch.

Bottom Line

While these Berkley gloves could use some design improvements and a little extra warmth for anglers working in cold temperatures, for the most part, they are an awesome choice. They’re versatile, provide some extra control, and look pretty cool, too. 

Palmyth Neoprene Fishing Gloves for Men and Women 2 Cut Fingers Flexible Great for Photography Fly Fishing Ice Fishing Running Touchscreen Texting Shooting Hiking Jogging Trekking Cycling Walking

Pros

  • Protection from cut
  • Sleek, attractive design
  • Breathable fabric prevents odor
  • Flip back finger design for easy access
  • Adjustable fit for a variety of hand sizes

Cons

  • The sizes run small
  • Not suited for super-cold weather
  • Material tends to wear down after several uses

What Recent Buyers Report

Those who bought the neoprene fishing gloves from Palmyth had many praises to give about several aspects of the design. Anglers were happy with the breathability and convenience of the construction, but many wished they were better-suited for cold weather and were a little more durable over time.

Why it Stands Out to Us

This pair of gloves ends up on our list because we love the unique design. It’s tough to find this kind of variation within the angling market, but we appreciate the flip back finger design and think it really adds to the convenience. We also enjoy the breathability of the fabric which leads to less of a need for washing and drying.

Who Will Use This Most

These particular gloves are not made to be used in super-cold weather. With that in mind, these are an exceptional choice for anglers who frequent streams and lakes on chilly mornings. They’re fairly versatile and have several features that make them convenient and easy to use.

Bottom Line

When it comes to fishing gloves, the Palmyth Neoprene Gloves are a pretty solid choice. With convenient features and exceptional grip strength, a pair of these might just make the difference in your angling experience.

Conclusion

All in all, cold weather fishing gloves are a great tool that can contribute to making your angling experience more comfortable during the winter months. While all the picks on our list are great options, if you don’t see a pair that strikes your fancy, ensure the ones you choose are durable and high quality and you’ll be set for success. Happy Fishing!

People Also Ask

If you still have questions about cold weather fishing gloves, you’re not alone! To ensure you’re getting the pair that will be the most beneficial to your fishing success, read through our FAQ to see what other anglers are asking,

What Types of Gloves Are Best for Fishing?

The best type of glove for cold-water fishing are those that are thin enough to provide ample dexterity without compromising warmth. They should have a waterproof outer layer and a thin, inner layer of insulation to keep your hands comfortable throughout a day on the water. 

How Do I Clean My Fishing Gloves?

To prevent odor and increase the longevity of your gloves, hand wash them every once in awhile with warm water and a gentle soap solution. Rinse with clean water and hang them to drip dry. Avoid washers and dryers to prevent potential damage.